Why do we feel happy when others are happy?
Let’s say you are at a store and there is a person who is giving chocolates to people who can beat him in a game of rock-paper-scissors. You decide to play against the man and end up winning; he gives you a chocolate. After your turn, your friend also decides to play against the man. He also ends up winning; he receives a chocolate. From this little thought experiment, we can form a bunch of interesting questions: Did you feel happiness during both victories? Did the magnitude of happiness differ between the two victories? What if a stranger won the chocolate instead of your friend, would you still be happy at the victory? What if you were allergic to chocolate and gave it to a sick child instead; Would you still feel happy? Let’s delve into each of these questions one by one. The answer to the first question is quite simple and doesn’t need much of an analysis — yes, happiness is felt during both victories as long as the friend is socially desirable and relatively similar. The second question however, is much more intriguing. The concept of impure altruism or “warm glow” was first coined by economist James Andreoni in 1989 and 1980, and it says that people care about helping others, but they also derive a selfish, personal emotional benefit from the act of giving itself. We however, will not be delving into the behavioral aspect of this phenomenon but rather the neural version of “pure altruism” which is known as a vicarious reward. Mobbs et al. 2009 showed that ventral striatum — a major reward region — rose in activity when a socially desirable contestant won a game show, and the same region was active when the volunteers themselves won. This partially answers our second question — even though happiness can clearly be felt during both victories, the difference in magnitude cannot be determined. Furthermore, the vicarious response grew with perceived similarity to the contestant, tracked by ventral anterior cingulate activity. This answers our third question — yes, happiness would still be felt but the magnitude of happiness would depend on similarity to the stranger. As for our last question, Harbaugh et al. 2007 showed that even mandatory, tax-like transfers to a charity elicited neural activity in reward-linked regions — pure altruism or vicarious reward — and activity rose further when the donation was voluntary — the warm glow effect. Unfortunately, no research done so far can answer question 2 fully as Mobbs et al. compared brain activity between the wins of socially desirable contestants with wins of undesirable contestants instead of friends.