The Tragedy of the Brain

Share
The Tragedy of the Brain

Imagine the following situation: You are a part of a group of lumberjacks staying in a forest. If you choose to cut down a tree, you get to keep all the wood but the cost of cutting down the tree — less trees left for everyone — is shared across your group. If everyone decides to act rationally as individuals, they will soon end up chopping down the entire forest, leaving no wood for any of them. This aberration is known as the “Tragedy of the Commons”. A common resource is formally described as a resource that is rivalrous (using it lowers the amount available to others) and non-excludable (it’s hard to stop people from using it). The reason behind the tragedy of the commons is quite simple, the benefits of using a common resource are saturated to the individual but the costs are shared across the whole group making it so that a person always has an incentive to use the resource, hence the resource ends up getting depleted. This anomaly sets up a marvellous set of ideas and experiments by acting as a social dilemma. Skeptics will ask the obvious question of, “How have many fisheries, forests and pastures been preserved for centuries? Is it because people are irrational?”. Ostrom, the 2009 nobel prize winner, proposed that the tragedy isn’t caused by the commons themselves but rather due to open access without rules. Ostrom’s key idea is that the use of common resources is not a one-shot prisoner’s dilemma but rather a repeated collective action that allows people to build trust, communicate, form rules and punish violators. The monitoring and punishing of violators is especially key to maintaining a common resource. Critics will however raise a fair question, “Who would actually be willing to pay the costs of enforcement and monitoring?”. We will be answering this question through neuroscience. A 2004 study by De Quervain et al. using PET scans showed that punishment that actually cut the defector’s payoff, activated the dorsal striatum (a major reward region of the brain) and people with stronger activation paid more to punish. If punishing defectors feels rewarding, that explains why people are willing to pay for enforcement. The observations from the studies however do come with caveats:

  • The study is small and used PET instead of fMRI
  • The striatum can be active for a bunch of reasons
  • Punishment being rewarding is a mere inference, not a stated fact.

This inference however does help explain why many individuals are willing to bear the cost of monitoring and enforcement services in social dilemmas like the tragedy of the commons.